Gabby Windey Claims Michael Bublé ‘Eye-F—– Me’ During Guest Judge Stint on DWTS ArticlePure

Gabby Windey is not a fan of Michael Bublé.

The Traitors winner, 34, recalled a less-than-pleasant interaction she had with the singer during her stint on Dancing with the Stars in 2022 on the April 3 episode of Bowen Yang and Matt Rogers’ podcast, Las Culturistas.

“Michael Bublé is beyond dead to me,” Windey said, acknowledging that this is “not the first, second, third, or fourth time” that she’s publicly talked “mad s—” on the singer.

“I will also scream it,” she said, before explaining the reason behind her passionate feelings.

“He, like, literally eye-f—– me, looked me up and down, on the way to my trailer,” she claimed. “I’m like, ‘I’m for sure getting a 10 out of this guy.'”

When Rogers suggested that perhaps Bublé, 49, was “trying to flirt” with her by only giving her a 9, not a 10, she replied, “I don’t know. That is not the way to flirt with me. I don’t do that.” Instead, she admitted, “I like the love bomb.”

Bublé’s rep did not immediately respond to PEOPLE’s request for comment.

Windey is far from the first DWTS contestant to have expressed some uncomfortable feelings about a guest judge.

On the most recent season, which aired through November and saw Bachelor alum Joey Graziadei take home the mirror ball, KISS bassist Gene Simmons was a guest judge and was heavily criticized on social media for comments he made about the contestants’ physical appearances.

“This is a brand new experience for me and it’s difficult to look at you and to figure out which one is more hot, hot, hot,” he told Danny Amendola and his partner Witney Carson after their performance.

“Danny, I’m telling you, you’re right next to somebody, one of the more beautiful women on the planet,” he continued, which left Carson with a bewildered look on her face.

Simmons made another comment later on in the episode about Chandler Kinney, as he said the actress “fogged up” his glasses. “You move me, not just with your gyrations and so on, but your beautiful face and how you were into the emotion of it,” he said.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer??, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Despite her encounter with Bublé, Windepy told PEOPLE in September that Dancing with the Stars was “such an amazing experience.”

“Anybody who gets the opportunity, I’m like, ‘Do Dancing with the Stars. It’s the best thing you can do ever.’”