Bachelor Alum Becca Tilley and Hayley Kiyoko Made Wedding Guest List ArticlePure

Becca Tilley and Hayley Kiyoko are miles ahead!

Speaking in a new interview with US Weekly on Tuesday, March 31, The Bachelor alum, 36, opened up about the couple’s hypothetical wedding guest list despite not being engaged.

This comes after the pair shared a snap from Tilley’s best friend Tanya Rad’s wedding earlier this month with Kiyoko, 33, writing in the caption, “Quote of the night ‘you’re next.’”

“Hayley was joking. Since I was one of the maid of honors, I was with Tanya most of the time. So Hayley was kind of on her own, and she said that so many people were coming up to her saying like, ‘Oh, you’re next or when is it y’all’s turn?’” Tilley said.

She continued, “Anytime we get to go and celebrate love, especially for our close friends, it makes that idea of us doing that sound so much fun.”

“Afterwards, we were so impressed with their guest list — everyone was so fun and got along and everyone mingled together — we were giving our hypothetical guest list of who would be invited,” Tilley added.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Tilley and Kiyoko, who began dating in 2018 before going public with their relationship in 2022, went on to speak about the idea of getting married.

“It’s something we talk about,” Tilley said. “What I love about our relationship is we very much do everything at our own pace. So I think if anything, it was such a weekend full of joy and love that it made us go like, ‘Oh, I can’t wait until that’s our weekend.’” 

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

The couple, who first met at Tilley’s release party for her debut album Expectations, went public with their relationship at the release party for Kiyoko’s single “For The Girls.“

“It feels really good,” Kiyoko told PEOPLE after going public with Tilley in 2022. “I mean, we lived a very normal life. It just wasn’t on social media. We lived very open. And we’ve been together for four years, but now it’s on social media. And now we get to share with the world. It’s just been really nice — we’ve had so much love and support.”